Never Again
This weeks experimentation with format sizes has come to an end. And I’m here to tell you my ruling has to do with the title of today’s strip. Never again. I thought it would be nice to get rid of the old tired horizontal four-panel format and go with something that would embrace today’s technology. The horizontal format hearkens back to the newspaper days where real estate was scarce. I thought it would be nice to make these strips bigger so they could be read more easily on phones and other mobile devices since I don’t have to worry about printing them.
Nope.
I found out I don’t really like working in the larger scale. I found I don’t really like seeing my strips that large because there’s nothing left to the imagination on the readers side (every line is magnified 10x and any mistakes are more obvious). On my end, it takes longer to produce one of these things and I struggle with the line weight being too thick. I can’t finesse my way though the artwork, everything is ham-handed and clunky. And the software itself loses the ability of some key features that speed my process up. Not to mention, it took several tries just to get the image uploaded.
For those who do work in that size, my hats off to you. As for me, no thanks.
I think I’ll just stick with the older 4 panel format, with the occasional 6 and 12 Sunday format.
Editors Note:
Ok, I was tired, perhaps I was ragey last night (or should I say this morning), and I just got finished watching the movie BFG (Big Friendly Giant) so I might not have been in my right mind when I posted this originally. I will re-evaluate the format situation and figure out a happy medium. Because… damn, today’s strip does look good on my iphone.
I really like your character’s awareness of the new format too
I did a few like this once but for some reason went back to the old way. I like that the readers can’t glimpse ahead to the end of the strip before they’ve read it all. I’m about to sit down & draw after lunch & you’ve inspired me to try this format again.
I’ll give it a try for a while. Not 100% sure about it but I think it’s because that’s not how I’ve done it and I’m not used to it.
Never a bad thing to experiment with the format once in awhile.
This is true. It’s good to change things up in general. If we don’t, things get stale and we become Snuffy Smith or Beetle Bailey.
I read this on my desktop computer, because I don’t like smartphones or Iphones, and get off my damned lawn. However, I SO love this comic that I’m happy to read it in whatever format you decide to publish it. Do what makes you happy, p.j., because if it stresses you too much, I might never see Duffy again. Or Carl. And that would make me sad.
Thanks for the kind words and thanks so much for reading. I shall do my best not to be a stressed artist and keep your weekly dose of Duffy and Carl flowing.
I typically read on my laptop but this time I caught it on my phone, and it looks beautiful.
Thanks Kim. It’s definitely big.
For what its worth, I like the bigger format. It was easier to read on my iPhone and it looks GREAT on a big PC monitor.
Yeah, after looking at it this morning, I’m tend to agree. i have to find something that works from all the formats. It does look good on my iPhone.
Honestly, I only read this strip because of the larger format because it works so well on My iphone. Embrace the 21st century. You are a webcomic, not a newspaper comic in 1955.
That’s so true. It’s a webcomic and the only reasons to go horizontal format is:
1. If I ever want to put my comics in a book (which after 3 years, hasn’t happened yet)
2. Because that’s the way it’s always been done (comfortable complacency is a killer in this business).
I’m thinking I need to re-evaluate my decision.
Thanks for the input.
Nice… lots of head room.
Don’t worry about the phone format. The regular strip format is fine.
Isn’t it nice of Duff to keep on surprising Carl? He’s such a great friend. 😀 😀
Unfortunately, lots of my readers are viewing on mobile devices. I need to find a way to make this work.
This strip reminds me of the joke about the guy who jumped off of a 10 story building
Well, it was pretty frIggin cool while it lasted
Yeah, I’m going try to find a happy medium here. I really want to go bigger, but I’m not happy with the outcome.